• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill: Authentic NY-Style Pizza & Grill in Madisonville

Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill is a beloved establishment in Madisonville, TN, known for its delicious offerings of pizza, barbeque, and sandwiches. With a range of amenities such as delivery, takeout, reservations, wheelchair accessibility, and more, Goodfellas ensures convenience for all diners. The location prides itself on its inclusive approach, offering services like ASL proficiency, Braille menus, and ADA-compliant facilities. The restaurant also provides a cozy ambiance with outdoor seating, TV screens, and friendly waiter service. Enjoy a taste of New York with a Tennessee twist at Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill.

Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill at a glance

  • Address 4445 Hwy 411 Madisonville, TN 37354
  • Phone (423) 545-9811
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill: Reviews & Ratings

Colin Hall
5

A hidden gem of a NY style pizza restaurant/takeout place. Ordered the Hawaiian, not very original to pick but so glad we did. The best things were they used fresh pineapple - I'm so used to tinned pineapple chunks that don't pack the amazing punch that the one on Goodfellas pizza did. Plus the tomato sauce base tasted of tomato! Definitely quality ingredients. Plus I often get "salt hangovers" the next day from pizzas but not from this one, so another big thumbs up for not flooding it with artificial flavours or salt. The restaurant was empty (we ate in) but the staff were busy prepping many takeaway meals. Would definitely recommend. Thanks for the best Hawaiian pizza I've ever had!

Sandy S
5

So much variety we couldn’t choose just one! We went half burger, half Philly cheesesteak pizza, and honestly… this might be the best pizza I’ve had in SF!

Afshin Afshar-Ghasemlou
4

GoodFella's Pizzeria & Grill has moved to a new location, just around the corner. This new space is bigger and quieter, which is a nice improvement. They are still working on the interior to make it look even better. The great news is that their pizza still tastes amazing—maybe even better! I’ve already visited twice since the move. The first time, I had a 12-inch pizza with half Hawaiian and half vegetarian toppings. The second time, I ordered half cheese and half pepperoni with pineapple. Both were delicious! The crust was thin and just right, and the ingredients were fresh and tasty. The pizzas were cooked perfectly, not burnt or undercooked. The service is always friendly and reminds me of the good pizza places I used to go to in New York. They have a nice seating area if you want to eat there. I highly recommend you try GoodFella’s next time you’re in the area. Let me know what you think!

Sohaib Khalid
5

Best Pizza, We tried kebabs platter, Chicken garlic Pizza and mozzarella sticks, taste was good and served with good portion size, this place is recommended.

Hillary Brobst
5

Food was really good. Great atmosphere and within walking distance of our hotel.

Hamed
5

Great pizza. Crispy crust, flavorful sauce, and plenty of fresh cheese. Every bite was on point. You can tell the toppings are high quality and evenly distributed. The staff is very friendly and welcoming. Definitely coming back.

Weiss Sekandari
5

These are 3 different slices I got: -Meatlover -Chicken garlic blanco -Cheeseburger pizza Slices are HUGE, loaded with toppings, only place in the area where you can get a meal for $10 and get full. The Cheeseburger pizza was probably the best pizza I ever had, taste like a in n out burger and spread sauce

Erwin van Rijsewijk
5

Nice waiter, very friendly. For Dutch people: small pizza is big enough for one BBQ chicken pizza is a good choice.

Location

  • Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill
    Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill
    4445 Hwy 411 Madisonville, TN 37354 Hotline: (423) 545-9811

Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill is not just your average pizzeria - it's a dining experience that combines the best of New York-style pizza, mouthwatering barbeque, and delicious sandwiches. Located at 4445 Hwy 411 in Madisonville, TN, this restaurant offers a variety of utilities to cater to all their guests' needs, from delivery and takeout options to wheelchair accessibility and ADA-compliant facilities.

The menu at Goodfellas is a testament to their dedication to quality and flavor. Whether you're in the mood for a classic pepperoni pizza, a savory barbeque platter, or a grilled sandwich stacked high with all your favorite toppings, this place has got you covered. And with options like QR code menus, Braille menus, and ASL proficiency, they ensure that every guest feels welcome and accommodated.

As a food reviewer, I have had the pleasure of trying out the dishes at Goodfellas, and let me tell you - they do not disappoint. The flavors are bold, the portions are generous, and the service is top-notch. From the first bite to the last, I was impressed by the attention to detail and the care put into each dish.

So if you're in the mood for some truly unforgettable food, do yourself a favor and pay a visit to Goodfellas New York Pizza & Grill. You won't be disappointed.

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Has outdoor seating
    • Offers kerbside pickup
    • Has no-contact delivery
    • Offers delivery
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards